Defense Brief

The Navy's Missing 174,000 Shipyard Workers: What the Numbers Do and Do Not Show

By Marcus Hale · November 17, 2026

Category: defense-geopolitical-news

The Navy's Missing 174,000 Shipyard Workers: What the Numbers Do and Do Not Show

A War on the Rocks essay says Navy yards are 174,000 workers short. We test the key shipbuilding workforce figures against public sources.

Key takeaways

  1. The problem Navy shipyards cannot hire and keep enough workers, and raises have not closed the gap.

  2. Core insight The 174,000 shortfall is an analyst figure, but GAO-documented delays and 50 to 60 percent first-year attrition show the problem is real.

  3. Practical outcome Judge workforce programs by whether they reach new entrants, and test paid training before scaling it.

The U.S. Navy's shipyards are 174,000 workers short, according to one War on the Rocks analysis, and a large wage increase has not closed the gap. The number explains why a submarine ordered today may arrive years late.

On October 7, 2026, War on the Rocks published "The Navy's Missing Welders Are Stocking Shelves" by Michael Gilroy, arguing that the Navy's workforce funding misses the people it most needs. This article takes the same subject and tests the main figures against their sources. Where a figure comes from the author or a single source, we say so.

The Numbers at a Glance

make a phone call, mobile, phone
Photo by VinzentWeinbeer on Pixabay
  • 174,000: workers the shipyards are short, per Gilroy's analysis (author's figure, not an official count).
  • 50 to 60 percent: first-year attrition across the yards, as told to the Senate in March 2025 by Brett Seidle, then the Navy's acting acquisition executive, per Gilroy.
  • About $57,000: starting wage for an entry-level welder at Newport News after Navy-funded raises, per Gilroy.
  • $53,750: median welder pay in the May 2025 Bureau of Labor Statistics survey, as cited by Gilroy.
  • 15,000: workers placed with more than 500 suppliers by six regional Talent Pipeline Programs since 2021, as cited by Gilroy.
  • $33,180: median pay of 3.09 million cashiers in the same BLS survey, as cited by Gilroy.

174,000: The Gap

mother and daughter, daughter, mom
Photo by keithdalmon on Pixabay

This is the headline figure and the weakest to verify. Gilroy states that the yards are still 174,000 workers short, but we could not trace it to a single public Navy document in the sources reviewed. Treat it as an analyst estimate. What can be verified is the direction. The Government Accountability Office told Congress in April 2026 that Navy and Coast Guard shipbuilding programs are, collectively, "billions of dollars over cost and years behind schedule," as stated on the GAO's page for testimony GAO-26-109068. GAO's page lists the shipbuilding trades workforce among the topics it reviewed. Gilroy adds that GAO named the workforce as one of two reasons the yards were not positioned to meet delivery goals. We could not confirm that wording on the GAO summary page, so readers should check the full testimony.

50 to 60 Percent: The Leak

woman, eyes, eyelashes
Photo by Bessi on Pixabay

Attrition shows why wages alone do not fix a workforce. If half or more of new hires leave in the first year, a yard must hire two people to keep one. Gilroy reports that raises at Electric Boat and Newport News Shipbuilding got both yards to their 2025 hiring targets and cut attrition by two to five percentage points, per the Navy's May 2026 shipbuilding plan. A two to five point cut is real but small against a base of 50 to 60 percent.

$57,000 Versus $33,180: The Wage Logic

The gap between a cashier's median pay and an entry-level welder's starting pay at Newport News is about $24,000, by Gilroy's numbers. The argument is that wage is no longer the barrier. The barrier is the months of unpaid training between jobs. A person living paycheck to paycheck cannot quit a job to attend daytime classes.

"What nobody has tried yet is recruiting a cashier at a mall forty miles away with the same money."

- Michael Gilroy, War on the Rocks, October 7, 2026

15,000: What Existing Programs Achieve

The Navy's pipeline is not idle. Gilroy credits six regional programs with more than 15,000 placements since 2021 and notes that the Southeastern New England Defense Industry Alliance has trained more than 10,000 people. He also cites 5,500 new classroom seats in 2025 by the Navy's own tally and about $100 million in a single year on a submarine recruiting campaign. The criticism is not that these programs fail. It is that none pays the trainee during training.

What the Numbers Cannot Tell You

  • They do not prove the fix. Evidence for paid-training intermediaries is mixed. Gilroy cites MDRC ten-year results in which one of four WorkAdvance programs raised earnings by 32 percent while the other three showed no effect by year ten.
  • They are not all official. The 174,000 gap and several wage numbers come from an opinion essay.
  • They hide skill mix. A shortage of 174,000 spans welders, machinists, electricians and designers. A welder trained in eight weeks is not a nuclear-qualified shipfitter.

What to Watch

  1. The Navy's response to the paid-training proposal and any funded pilot.
  2. Updated GAO findings on whether the yards meet delivery dates.
  3. Attrition figures for fiscal 2026 from Electric Boat and Newport News.

The workforce is one of several industrial constraints. Our article on Anduril's Arsenal-2 and submarine components covers the supply side, and our defense industrial base guide places shipbuilding alongside munitions.

Why This Is a Strategic Problem

A shortage of welders can look like a local labor story. It is a strategy story. A navy is a stock of hulls, and hulls are built by people. When a yard delivers a ship late, the fleet that planners counted on is smaller on the day it is needed. Our Indo-Pacific maritime guide explains why numbers of hulls matter in the western Pacific, where distances are long and ships cannot be everywhere.

The workforce also competes across programs. The same regions that build submarines and destroyers supply the second- and third-tier suppliers for missile airframes, castings and electronics. When the Pentagon signs multi-year deals such as the $24.4 billion SM-6 agreement, it assumes that suppliers can hire. If suppliers cannot, the contract value does not turn into deliveries. That is why labor appears in so many industrial base analyses, including CSIS work on munitions lead times that have stretched from about 24 months to 36 months or more for first delivery.

The practical lesson is to measure the right thing. A program that counts placements tells you how many people started. A program that counts retained workers after twelve months tells you how many ships can be built. The second number is harder to produce and more useful.

Final Assessment

The figures that carry weight are the ones tied to public records: GAO's finding of years of delay, the BLS wage data and the Navy's own shipbuilding plan. The 174,000 shortfall is a useful estimate and nothing more. The strongest idea in the essay is narrow and testable: pay people while they learn, then measure whether new entrants arrive. The Navy could run that trial this year.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many workers are Navy shipyards short?

One War on the Rocks analysis puts it at 174,000. It is an author's figure, not an official Navy count.

What is first-year attrition at the yards?

Brett Seidle, then the Navy's acting acquisition executive, told the Senate in March 2025 that it runs 50 to 60 percent, as cited by Gilroy.

Did wage increases help?

Yes, modestly. Gilroy reports that raises helped two yards reach 2025 hiring targets and cut attrition by two to five points.

What does GAO say about Navy shipbuilding?

GAO told Congress in April 2026 that Navy and Coast Guard programs are billions of dollars over cost and years behind schedule.